Tribe Wins Fight to Limit Research of Its DNA
Posted: April 21, 2010.
Print: New York Times
excerpt:
But months later, tribe members learned more about the research when a university investigation discovered two dozen published articles based on the blood samples that Dr. Markow had collected. One reported a high degree of inbreeding, a measure that can correspond with a higher susceptibility to disease.
Ms. Tilousi found that offensive….
Another article, suggesting that the tribe’s ancestors had crossed the frozen Bering Sea to arrive in North America, flew in the face of the tribe’s traditional stories that it had originated in the canyon and was assigned to be its guardian.
Listening to the investigators, Ms. Tilousi felt a surge of anger, she recalled. But in Supai, the initial reaction was more of hurt. Though some Havasupai knew already that their ancestors most likely came from Asia, “when people tell us, ‘No, this is not where you are from,’ and your own blood says so — it is confusing to us,” Rex Tilousi said. “It hurts the elders who have been telling these stories to our grandchildren.”








So… A bunch of people get hurt feelings because it turns out that reality doesn’t support their ancestral stories… And that’s worth the cost of 2.4 million USD to the side that’s only primary concern is the fair representation of reality?
That’s fucking nuts.
posted on April 22, 2010report this as inappropriate
You don't have permission to flag this entry.