Archive
Archive Categories
Science v Religion
Religion and Public Policy
Religion and Politics
Secular Morality
Evolution v. Creationism/ID
Psychology and the Sciences of Mind
Physical Science
Life Science
Islam
Christianity
Judaism
Hinduism
Buddhism
New Religions (Mormonism, Scientology, Cults, etc.)
Comedy
Archive Articles
Kibbutz
Tony Judt
January 19, 2010
Print: NYRBlog
Excerpt from a memoir of life in an Israeli Kibbutz with discussion of the author’s growing disillusionment with Labour Zionism. “What I did, however, come quite quickly to understand if not openly acknowledge was just how limited the kibbutz and its members really were. The mere fact of collective self-government, or egalitarian distribution of consumer durables, does not make you either more sophisticated or more tolerant of others. Indeed, to the extent that it contributes to an extraordinary smugness of self-regard, it actually reinforces the worst kind of ethnic solipsism.”








